Verdict
2024 Tesla Model Y earns 7.3/10 in the CarsbySpec specification-led assessment and places 27th of 83 among nearby electric SUVs. Practicality is its strongest measured area. Range and efficiency is the principal numerical compromise.
Its value-for-money score is 7.6/10, placing it 21st of 76. The strongest value score in this peer set belongs to the 2024 Chevrolet Equinox EV.
This makes the review useful for building a shortlist, but it cannot answer questions that require driving the car. Ride comfort, cabin noise, steering response, braking consistency and material quality should still be checked in person.
Performance
The Standard Range RWD version used as the baseline records 271 hp, 420 Nm of torque, 6.9 seconds from 0-100 km/h, and a 201 km/h top speed. Its power output ranks 46th of 83 among entries with comparable data. Its acceleration ranks 44th of 79 among entries with comparable data.
These figures describe straight-line potential only. They do not reveal brake feel, grip in poor conditions, steering accuracy, stability or how consistently the car performs after repeated acceleration and braking.
Range, efficiency and charging
The recorded energy picture includes 402 km of listed electric range, a 57.5 kWh battery, 170 kW maximum DC charging, and 15.5 kWh/100km recorded consumption. Its listed range ranks 67th of 82 among entries with comparable data.
Published range and consumption can come from different regional cycles. Temperature, speed, wheel size, load and charging conditions can materially change the result, so the figures should be compared on the same test method wherever possible.
Interior space and everyday usability
For daily use, the specification lists 854 litres of cargo capacity, 5 seats, and a 1,909 kg curb weight. Its cargo capacity ranks 5th of 81 among entries with comparable data.
Capacity figures still need context: a large boot can be compromised by a narrow opening or high floor, and a seat count does not establish adult comfort. Those points require an inspection rather than a spreadsheet.
Safety and driver assistance
A verified Euro NCAP result is stored for this model year or an explicitly covered unchanged generation. Ratings from different authorities, markets and protocol years are shown on their own scales and are not converted into a CarsbySpec safety score.
CarsbySpec does not treat curb weight, drivetrain or driver-assistance marketing as proof of crash safety. Before buying, verify the exact market version, standard safety equipment and outstanding recalls; a result from another generation is never silently reused.
Known problems and used-buying checks
CarsbySpec has not yet stored a sourced fault record that can be safely attached to this exact model year and generation. That is a coverage gap, not evidence that the car is fault-free.
Used Tesla Model Y inspection checklist
Recall status and service campaigns can change after publication. Check the exact VIN with the manufacturer or the relevant national authority, and use an independent pre-purchase inspection.
Price and value for money
The baseline starting price is $43,990 USD. That price ranks 32nd of 76 among entries with comparable data. Its value-for-money score is 7.6/10, placing it 21st of 76. The strongest value score in this peer set belongs to the 2024 Chevrolet Equinox EV.
The value score combines starting price with performance, range and cargo figures where available. It does not assume identical taxes, incentives, warranties, servicing or standard equipment across countries, so local quotations still matter.
Which version should you choose?
There are 4 recorded 2024 versions. On the available price and specification data, the Long Range gives the strongest numerical balance of cost, performance, range and capacity. That is a value calculation rather than a claim about trim quality or equipment not stored in the database.
| Version | Power | 0-100 | Range | Price | Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Model Y Standard Range RWD | 271 hp | 6.9 s | 402 km | $43,990 | |
| Model Y Long Range | 351 hp | 5.0 s | 542 km | $44,990 | Value pick |
| Model Y Long Range AWD | 384 hp | 5.0 s | 531 km | $48,990 | |
| Model Y Performance AWD | 510 hp | 3.7 s | 482 km | $52,490 |
Which similar car is best?
The highest overall specification score in this electric SUV group belongs to the 2026 Cadillac VISTIQ at 8.5/10. For value, the leading result is the 2024 Chevrolet Equinox EV at 9.1/10. These are data-led results, not universal buying recommendations.
